December 25, 2024
Chicago 12, Melborne City, USA
Dear Diary

A Shoe Review

I mostly like that title because it rhymes and sounds a bit like “view halloo”.

Not that I approve of fox-hunting, it just makes me think of Mary Poppins. Anyway, enough nonsensical wittering. Today I am going to review a pair of shoes.

About a week ago I got an email from the Most Wanted people at Vouchercodes about a “seasonal staples” campaign. The idea is that they will get several bloggers to review a key item each season based on the criteria of comfort, style and price then collate those into a comparison on the Most Wanted site.

This appealed to me because I love a good product comparison, but also because the people offering me free shoes to review weren’t the people who sell the shoes, so no lingering resentment should they happen to be rubbish. I’m happy to say I’m always honest in my reviews, no matter who sends me them!

I have been sent these patent loafers from Very.co.uk at the very reasonable price of Ā£28.

Before I start I DO have to mention that if you order these loafers from Very they will very likely be delivered to you by a company called Yodel. They used to be Home Delivery Network, and the change of name hasn’t improved the service. These shoes were delivered sometime last week, I don’t know when as all that was written on the card that came through my door was a house number in the “left with neighbour” box. Unfortunately that number was MY house number, leading me to believe that my delivery driver must have been mentally deficient in some way. It took me 4 days to finally get someone on the phone (they promised to call me back and didn’t) before I finally tracked down the shoes.

That’s not a reflection on the shoes, so does not form part of my review, but it is an issue to take into account before ordering anything.

On the website it says the shoes are South but the box and inside of the Shoe is Love Label. I’m sure there’s some reason for that, but I don’t know what it is!

First impressions are fairly good.Ā  The styling of them is nice. They have a lovely elegant classic look, and are fairly sturdy. There’s no unnecessary studs or buckles in an attempt to make them look trendy. Just a nice, classic, penny loafer.

If you get up close then they look slightly cheap as it’s obvious they’re not leather, but in general wear they’re very stylish.

When I put them on I could tell at once they weren’t going to be comfortable. I wore them to the shops with a pair of those little anklet stocking things. They were stiff to walk in, didn’t bend easily at the ball of the foot and dug in slightly at the heel. I also felt the right foot was much tighter than the left. I know feet can vary in size, but it’s not a problem I normally have.

I did experiment with wearing them without stockings, I figured a car journey where the only walking I was expected to was from the car to a motorway service station was a good opportunity and offered little opportunity for crippling me. I was wrong, and by the time I reached my destination I was actually limping as the stiff backs rubbed badly on my heels. Basically, these are DEFINITELY shoes you need socks or stockings with!

I get the feeling these shoes will soften up with time, but brand new they are tough to walk in. They look good, but the problem is, when I buy flat shoes I buy them because I want to be able to walk in them. Flat shoes to me are something I throw on for an all day shopping trip, and I think these will need significant wearing in before I could trust them on a whole day out. I was also slightly concerned about the amount of wear already showing on the soles after the very small amount of outdoor walking I did in them.

Overall, if you are looking for a pair of loafers to create a “look” these are a good buy at Ā£28. If you’re prepared to get them re-soled and heeled they’ll probably last you a good amount of time and soften up a little. But for Ā£28 you don’t get leather, you get plastic that rubs and sticks and squeaks, so just don’t expect to be able to wear them barefoot with rolled up jeans for a casual 50s sex kitten look.

For Autumn I’ll wear them with stockings and my beige raincoat, and I’ll hope I look as elegant as Suzy Parker.

 

These shoes were sent to me for free to review, but all opinions are definitely my own.
In the interests of total transparency as part of the seasonal staples campaign
bloggers are also given Ā£35 in ASOS vouchers.
I have no idea yet what to spend mine on. Suggestions welcome.

8 Comments

  • Jem September 23, 2011

    It’s something I dread when buying shoes – that they’re good for a try on/brief walk around the shop but shocking uncomfortable for anything more than that and unlikely to mould to my foot without considerable wear. Not a thing I’m likely to do if they eat my feet . . . argh, always a circular thing!

    They really are lookers though!

    Jem xXx

  • Lori Smith September 23, 2011

    They look lovely, but the use of a dreadful delivery service (if Very.co.uk use them on a regular basis, I definitely won’t be ordering from them!) and the fact they’re not leather is a definite no-no for me, so thanks for the warning. Flat shoes that hurt you have no point whatsoever! Still… they’re very shiny šŸ™‚

  • mystyle September 23, 2011

    Hi there!! What a shame they’re not comfy, they look great but I too like flats that are painfree and comfy on wearing straightaway!

  • lady liquor vintage. September 23, 2011

    as much as the shoes look lovely, i think Ā£28 for a pair of non-leather shoes is a bit steep! and i couldn’t cope with the rubbing either, my feet get obliterated every new pair i buy!

    xoxo.

  • Steph (mrs_sock) September 24, 2011

    I love the colour & look of these but I too want flat shoes that are immediately comfy. My nan once told me that if shoes aren’t comfy when you try them on, it’s unlikely they ever will be. She’s not wrong!

  • Jessie in Fashion Limbo September 24, 2011

    Have to agree with Steph and her nan šŸ™‚ I got a pair of leopard print flat loafers from Zara and whilst trying them on they felt sort of ok, as soon as i wore them the pain was terrible. I thought that by wearing them more they would cease to attemtp to murder my toes, but I have worn them a lot, and they do not get andy more comfortable. They also were not cheap… damn Zara.
    Great review Gemma xxxx

  • I do love a good penny loafer, sadly these do not sound like a good penny loafer ;o)

  • Markie September 30, 2011

    Very now have a collect+ option, which ive used and is free and very good!

    you can collect from a local collect+ place, search for one nearby, mine is my local westgate store, and you can return items here for free also!!

    i used to work for home delivery network so avoid at all costs, so luckily Very have an alternative option!!

Comments are closed.